Service

Agency Insurance Company (AIC)

General

Address
PO Box 8900
Elkridge, MD 21075-8900

Phone
1-800-492-5629

Website
Click Here

Policy Access
Click Here

AM Best Rating
B++ (Good)

Billing

Pay Online
Click Here

Pay By Phone
1-800-492-5629

Pay By Mail

Agency Insurance Company
P.O Box 8900
Elkridge, MD 21075
Overnight Payments
Agency Insurance Company
7450 Coca Cola Drive
Hanover, MD 21076

Claims

Phone
1-800-841-5241

American Modern

General

Address
PO Box 5323
Cincinnati, OH 45201-5323

Phone
1-866-884-6167

Website
Click Here

Policy Access
Click Here

AM Best Rating
A+ (Superior)

Billing

Pay Online
Click Here (Credit Card Payment)
Click Here (EFT Payment)

Pay By Phone
1-800-543-2644

Pay By Mail

American Modern Insurance Group
PO Box 5323
Cincinnati, Ohio 45201-5323
Overnight Payments
American Modern Insurance Group
Attn: account payment processing
7000 Midland Blvd.
Amelia, Ohio 45102-2607

Claims

Phone
1-800-375-2075

Report Online
Click Here

American Strategic Insurance (ASI)

General

Address
1 ASI Way
St. Petersburg, FL 33702

Phone
1-866-274-8765

Website
Click Here

Policy Access
Click Here

AM Best Rating
A (Excellent)

Billing

Pay Online
Click Here

Pay By Phone
1-866-274-5677

Pay By Mail

American Strategic Insurance
P.O Box 33018
St. Petersburg, FL 33733-8018

Claims

Phone
1-866-274-5677

Report Online
Click Here

Bristol West (Foremost Auto)

General

Address
P.O. Box 31029
Independence, OH 44131-0029

Phone
1-888-888-0080

Website
Click Here

Policy Access
Click Here

AM Best Rating
A (Excellent)

Billing

Pay Online
Click Here

Pay By Phone
1-888-888-0080 Foremost Auto Only (Bristol West)

Pay By Mail

Foremost Auto Only (Bristol West)
Bristol West Insurance
P.O. Box 371329
Pittsburgh, PA 15250-7329

Claims

Phone
1-800-274-7865 Foremost Auto Only (Bristol West)

Report Online
Click Here

FirstComp

General

Address
P.O. Box 3009
Omaha, NE 68102

Phone
1-888-500-3344

Website
Click Here

Policy Access
Click Here

AM Best Rating
B++ (Good)

Billing

Pay Online
Click Here

Pay By Phone
1-888-500-3344

Pay By Mail

FirstComp
P.O. Box 2329
Omaha, NE 68103-2329

Claims

Phone
1-888-500-3344

Email
FROI@firstcomp.com

Foremost Insurance Group

General

Address
5600 Beech Tree Lane
Caledonia, MI 49316

Phone
1-800-527-3905

Website
Click Here

Policy Access
Click Here

AM Best Rating
A (Excellent)

Billing

Pay Online
Click Here

Pay By Phone
1-800-532-4221 All Foremost products (except auto)

Pay By Mail

All Foremost products (except auto)
Foremost Insurance Group
Carol Stream, IL 60132-0915
Overnight Payments
Foremost – Box #915
c/o Citibank Lockbox Operations
8430 W Bryn Mawr Avenue, 3rd Floor
Chicago, IL 60631

Claims

Phone
1-800-527-3907 All Foremost products (except auto)

Report Online
Click Here

Frederick Mutual Insurance Company

General

Address
57 Thomas Johnson Drive
Frederick, MD 21702-4301

Phone
1-800-544-8737

Website
Click Here

Policy Access
Click Here

AM Best Rating
A- (Excellent)

Billing

Pay Online
Click Here

Pay By Phone
240-405-1888

Pay By Mail

Frederick Mutual Ins Co
57 Thomas Johnson Drive
Frederick, MD 21702-4301

Claims

Phone
1-800-544-8737

Report Online
Click Here

Grange Insurance

General

Address
671 South High Street
Columbus, OH 43206

Phone
1-800-422-0550

Website
Click Here

Policy Access
Click Here

AM Best Rating
A (Excellent)

Billing

Pay Online
Click Here

Pay By Phone
1-800-425-1100

Pay By Mail

Grange Insurance Companies
P.O. Box 740604
Cincinnati, OH 45274-0604
Overnight Payments
Grange Insurance Companies
671 South High Street
Columbus, OH 43206-1066

Claims

Phone
1-800-445-3030
1-800-951-9734 (Auto Glass)

Infinity Auto Insurance

General

Address
3700 Colonnade Parkway
Birmingham, AL 35243

Phone
1-800-782-1020

Website
Click Here

Policy Access
Click Here

AM Best Rating
A (Excellent)

Billing

Pay Online
Click Here

Pay By Phone
1-800-782-1020

Pay By Mail

Infinity Insurance
P.O. Box 830693
Birmingham, AL 35283-0693

Claims

Phone
1-800-334-1661

Kemper Preferred

General

Address
12926 Gran Bay Parkway West
Jacksonville, FL 32258

Phone
1-877-252-7878

Website
Click Here

Policy Access
Click Here

AM Best Rating
A- (Excellent)

Billing

Pay Online
Click Here

Pay By Phone
1-877-488-7488

Pay By Mail

Kemper Preferred
P.O. Box 70839
Charlotte, NC 28272

Claims

Phone
1-888-252-2799

Merchants Insurance Group

General

Address
250 Main Street
Buffalo, NY 14202

Phone
1-800-462-1077

Website
Click Here

Policy Access
Click Here

AM Best Rating
A- (Excellent)

Billing

Pay Online
Click Here

Pay By Phone
1-800-462-8182

Pay By Mail

Merchants Insurance Group
P.O. Box 4031
Buffalo, NY 14240

Claims

Phone
1-800-322-8608
1-888-644-6680 (After Hours)
1-877-446-0431 (Auto Glass)
1-866-328-5771 (Roadside Assistance)

Report Online
Click Here

National General Insurance

General

Address
P.O. Box 3199
Winston-Salem, NC 27102

Phone
1-800-462-2123

Website
Click Here

Policy Access
Click Here

AM Best Rating
A- (Excellent)

Billing

Pay Online
Click Here

Pay By Phone
1-800-462-2123

Pay By Mail

National General Insurance
P.O. Box 89431
Cleveland, OH 44101-6431

Claims

Phone
1-800-325-1088

Report Online
Click Here

Progressive Insurance

General

Address
P.O. Box 6807
Cleveland, OH 44101-1807

Phone
1-800-776-4737

Website
Click Here

Policy Access
Click Here

AM Best Rating
A+ (Superior)

Billing

Pay Online
Click Here

Pay By Phone
1-800-776-4737

Pay By Mail

Money Order/Cashier’s Check payments:
Progressive Insurance
Attn: Cash Processing
P.O. Box 94561
Payments without coupon or Online Bill Pay Service:
Progressive Insurance
DEPT. 0561
Carol Stream, IL 60132-0561

Claims

Phone
1-800-274-4499
1-888-776-2778 (Roadside Assistance)

Report Online
Click Here

Zurich Small Business

General

Address
PO BOX 2248
Grand Rapids, MI 49501

Phone
1-866-972-7378

Website
Click Here

Policy Access
Click Here

AM Best Rating
A+ (Superior)

Billing

Pay Online
Click Here

Pay By Phone
1-855-866-6879

Pay By Mail

Zurich
PO Box 4666
Carol Stream, IL 60197

Claims

Phone
1-800-987-3373 (Workers Compensation Only)
1-800-435-7764

Report Online
Click Here